Hermione Granger


Hermione Granger Was too Perfect. Is It Ruined Her Arc?


In the Harry Potter novels, Hermione Granger character development was strengthened by the fact that she had her own set of defects, but the movies destroyed this by making her too flawless.

Hermione Granger’s character was portrayed in the movies as being much more flawless than it was in the Harry Potter novels, which eventually had an effect on the way her friendships with other characters were understood by the audience.

Since there is often not enough time to fully investigate the complexities of a character’s literary persona in an adaptation of a book for the big screen, it may be challenging to include such nuances into the story.

Because of this, the character may end up being less complex than they were in the original source material. That meant that the character Hermione from the Harry Potter series lost a significant number of the defects that contributed to her overall interestingness.

Hermione was exactly the same arrogant know-it-all that she was in the novel when she was initially shown in the Harry Potter and the Philosopher’s Stone film adaptation for the first time.

This trait, on the other hand, faded away as time passed in the character’s development. The same was true – to some extent – for her counterpart in the book, as Hermione did mature and realize that she could not expect to have friends if she continuously spoke down to people. This was true for both Hermione and her counterpart in the novel.


Yet, this defect was never totally rectified. In point of fact, Hermione became better at offering unsolicited advice as she got older; yet, it seemed as if her ideas grew even more set in stone as she got older; this is a significant departure from how she was portrayed in the movies.

In the Harry Potter books, Hermione Granger may be rather closed up in her thinking at times.

Hermione Granger
Hermione Granger

In spite of the fact that in the Harry Potter films, Hermione grows into a wonderful witch and friend who never makes any errors, Hermione from the books is capable of causing a great deal of trouble due to the fact that she is so inflexible.

Throughout the Harry Potter book series, Hermione had always been opinionated, but by the time the story came to a close in Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince, she had become almost hard to convince of anything.

After she had reached her conclusion, she had a hard time opening her mind sufficiently to contemplate the possibility that she was incorrect. Because of this shortcoming, the character became intrinsically more engaging and approachable to the audience.

When it came to the ideas of others, particularly those of Harry, who relied far more on instinct than reasoning, Hermione had a tendency to be rather cruel. This was especially true of Harry’s opinions.

Hermione basically laughed in Harry’s face, sneered, and rolled her eyes anytime he brought up the possibility that Draco had become a Death Eater when Harry had the suspicion that Draco had become one.


Later, in Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows, she fought with Harry regarding the existence of the Hallows objects, arguing that it was impossible for them to exist and that he was wasting his time even thinking about them. This scene takes place in Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows. Naturally, Harry was in the right in both scenarios; nevertheless, Hermione refused to acknowledge this fact.

Hermione had to come to terms with the fact that not every problem can be solved by logic.

Hermione Granger
Hermione Granger

Harry Potter has been given another chance at life on several occasions because of Hermione Granger’s quick wit and meticulous reasoning, and he has always valued her capacity to assist him to work through difficulty.

Nevertheless, as time went on, Hermione developed an unhealthy reliance on her rationality and often failed to see the significance of following her instincts. This was something that Harry possessed in plenty, and it was one of the things that often put them on opposite sides of the argument in the novels.

In Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince, Hermione never apologized to Harry for being incorrect about Draco, despite the fact that, as far as she knew, it had resulted in Dumbledore’s death. Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix In addition, she continued to dismiss Harry’s intuition over the next year as they were searching for the Horcrux.

Hermione had always been certain that the objects in the Deathly Hallows could not possibly be genuine. Nonetheless, Harry demonstrated that they were in the end. Because Harry’s entire story defied logic, from the moment he overcame Voldemort’s Killing Curse as a baby to their final Harry Potter battle with the Elder Wand, and because this logic-defying quality was precisely why Voldemort never saw Harry’s victory coming, it was impossible for him to predict that Harry would prevail.

Voldemort was a brilliant man, but he was oblivious to the fact that there were inexplicable forces at work, which went beyond what could be explained logically. Despite the fact that Hermione was on the side of good, she still needed to learn the lesson. Logic has a place in the world, but there are some situations in which it is more important to follow one’s emotions.


The Perfection of Hermione Granger in the Harry Potter Films Had an Effect on Her Relationships

Hermione Granger
Hermione Granger

Hermione Granger was a character in the Harry Potter novels who had a lot of lovely flaws. Her arc was delightful because it showed her coming to terms with the fact that intelligence and academic success are not the only things that matter in life.

The trip was also the reason why her relationship with Ron turned out to be so successful. Both of them were flawed personalities who were able to find some kind of equilibrium in one another.

When Ron departed in “The Deathly Hallows,” Hermione learned to let go of the past and appreciate the many forms of brilliance, while Ron learned to let go of his envy after Hermione left. In the movies, when Ron’s flaws were really emphasized, Hermione’s personality, which was shown as being unrealistically flawless, did not align well with his.

However, since Harry and Hermione’s relationship was shown as being so flawless in the films, despite the absence of their fights, the pair’s connection seemed to be far stronger on the screen. Audience members would not be able to understand that Harry saw Hermione as a domineering and at times aggravating elder sister if Harry did not share his inner conversation with them.

Hermione Granger


Even though he liked and valued her, there was no way that they could have had a romantic relationship. Hermione Granger from the Harry Potter films may have been an excellent choice for the Boy Who Lived, but Hermione from the books is by far the more intriguing character.



What do you think?

2.6k Points
Upvote Downvote

Written by Wizarding Worldz

Latest news and updates on Wizarding World and we cover everything you need to know about sci-fi, fantasy, horror, and comics movies.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

GIPHY App Key not set. Please check settings

    Draco Malfoy Redemption Arc

    Draco Malfoy Redemption Arc : Is He Deserved it?

    Harry Potter Lucius Malfoy

    Harry Potter Lucius Malfoy Story: Was It Cut In Movie?